Feature request - make real Shuffle mode (not random)

[happyuser]

- make real Shuffle mode (not random).

The current approach of shuffle mode in playlist is not optimal. It actually should be called Random, not shuffle.

Please, make it shuffle, as it's much more convenient.

Shuffle is different from Random as actually should do this:
- When Shuffle is activated or playlist is loaded the playlist items should be randomly reordered in memory.
- The items in playlist window should stay the same (as it it now)
- The playback and Next/Previous buttons in playlist should change active media according to shuffled (reordered) list in the memory.

Advantages of real shuffle over current Random:
1) Playback do not play the same item twice or more times before other items are played.
2) Next and Previous buttons work perfectly (currently Previous button is broken, see separate issue).

[Kresimir]

I second this request. Apart from pl_next and pl_previous not working as expected with the shuffle option turned on, there is also the issue of the the first file in the playlist always playing first.

[rvm]

Implemented in svn r9313.

[happyuser]

[ehrichweiss]

I might not be understanding this new feature but the shuffle button no longer works for me in any way that I might expect. I'm using smplayer 20.60.0 on Gentoo x64

Most of the time when I load videos it sorts by order added(but not the shuffle order) by default. If I hit the shuffle button it will change the numbers in the shuffle order column but when I hit the "next" button it will go to the video next in the normal order, without the shuffle working at all.

Now sometimes, and I can't seem to duplicate this behavior, it will start shuffling as I would expect but I can usually only make that happen maybe one out of every ten attempts or so. It seems to take some weird combo of hitting the shuffle order column sort and then maybe the name sort and then maybe the add order sort. It's really hard to say what causes it but from what I can tell the OLD shuffle was much better as it didn't require all this nonsense to get it to work properly. Also, unless I'm misunderstanding the OP, I never saw the behavior they described regarding changing the order of the videos in the playlist but, again, I would have it sort via the order it was added so it never changed for me as far as I'm aware.

[rvm]

Please try version 21.1.